Indulge in our signature lasagna at McCordsville.
From Staten Island to McCordsville
The Goodfellas story began with a simple mission: to master the art of the perfect crust. Our roots stretch back to the legendary brick oven traditions of New York, where our signature recipes—like the world-famous Pizza Alla Vodka—first took the culinary world by storm.
In 2007, owner Abul Rahman brought that high-heat mastery to McCordsville. With a background in elite hospitality, Abul envisioned a place where world-class, award-winning pizza could be served with the warmth and personal touch of a neighborhood gathering spot. For nearly 20 years, we have been the "hidden secret" of the Geist area, serving generations of families the same gold-standard slices that won us the title of World Champions in Las Vegas.
800 Degrees of Authenticity
What makes a Goodfella? It’s the brick oven. Our stone-hearth oven reaches blistering temperatures that a standard deck oven simply can’t match.
More Than Just a Pizzeria
We believe the best meals are shared. Whether you’re sitting in one of our 11 cozy booths, catching the game at our full-service bar, or enjoying a sunset on our outdoor patio, you aren't just a customer—you’re a regular.
We take pride in being the go-to spot for post-game celebrations, local school fundraisers, and quiet date nights. At Goodfellas, the oven is always hot, the beer is always cold, and the service always feels like home
Bring the World's Best Home
Don't wait for a table to enjoy a world champion pie. Order your favorites online for a fast, fresh pickup or neighborhood delivery.
Order for Pickup: Swing by 9641 Olio Road and we’ll have your brick-oven pizza ready to go.
Order Delivery: Serving the Geist, McCordsville, and Fishers communities with hot, fresh delivery.