World-Class Catering for Your Local Events
Bring the "World’s Best Pizza" to your next gathering. From stone-fired pizza bundles to pans of classic Italian pasta, we make hosting in McCordsville and Geist easy and delicious.
Indulge in our signature lasagna at McCordsville.
Pizza Party Perfection
Our bundles are designed to take the guesswork out of ordering for a crowd.
The McCordsville Executive: 5 Large Specialty Pizzas, 2 Trays of Signature Breadsticks, and a Large Garden Salad. (Feeds 15–20)
The Geist Boat Pack: 3 Large 2-Topping Pizzas and 20 Oven-Roasted Wings. Easy to grab and go for a day on the water.
The Neighborhood Block Party: 10 Large Pizzas (Mix of 1-Topping and Specialty) plus 3 Trays of Breadsticks and 2-Liter Sodas. (Feeds 30–40)
Complete the Spread
Signature Breadstick Trays: 24 or 48 hand-twisted sticks with dipping sauces.
Goodfellas Garden Salad: Fresh greens, pepperoni, ham, and mozzarella with house vinaigrette.
Caesar Salad: Crisp romaine, shaved parmesan, and garlic croutons.
Serving McCordsville, Geist, and Fishers
We are proud to fuel the community. Goodfellas is the top choice for:
Corporate Lunches: Reliable delivery to Olio Road offices and local businesses.
School & Sports Events: Post-game meals for Mt. Vernon and Hamilton Southeastern teams.
Family Celebrations: Birthdays, graduations, and rehearsal dinners made easy.
Geist Boat Days: Fast, hot pickup on your way to the reservoir.